YouTube demands Clearview AI to stop scrapping its videos

SiliconANGLE | February 06, 2020

  • Google and its sprawling YouTube empire urged Clearview to cease slurping any more images from its videos and web pages.

  • Twitter sent a cease-and-desist letter to Clearview last month, addressing the same issue.

  • Clearview AI founder Hoan Ton-That believes his New-York City-based business has a “First Amendment right to public information.


Along with Twitter, Google-owned YouTube has become the latest one to send a cease-and-desist letter to Clearview AI, the startup behind a controversial facial recognition program that more than 600 police departments across North American use.
 

Clearview came under scrutiny earlier this year when The New York Times showed that the company had been scraping billions of images on the internet to build its database of faces. Their AI technology can use an image of a person and then find more links where that face has appeared.
 

The company has been claimed that it has more than 3 billion images in that database, images that were scrapped from Facebook, Twitter, YouTube, and other websites. In January 2020, Twitter Inc. demanded that Clearview stop collecting photos for any reason from its app and delete photos already it has in the database. At the same time, a group of U.S. senators expressed that such technology was an invasion of people’s privacy.
 

And now Google LLC has asked Clearview to stop scrapping YouTube videos for its database as well as delete any facial data that is already gathered. It has sent a cease-and-desist letter further.
 

In an interview with CBS This Morning, the company's CEO, Hoan Ton-That, said Clearview plans to challenge the cease-and-desist letters in court. Ton-That compared Clearview's practice of scraping the internet for images to what Google does with its search engine. "Google can pull in information from all different websites," he said. "So if it's public, you know, and it's out there, it could be inside Google search engine, it can be inside ours as well." He then went on to argue the company has a First Amendment right to public information.


“The way we have built our system is to only take publicly available information and index it.”

-Hoan Ton-That, CEO, Clearview



Clearview may be in a legally precarious position since it likely does not have explicit permission to use many, if not the vast majority, of the photos its service relies on. Still, it’s not clear how enforceable YouTube’s terms of service are in this case.

 

But YouTube, Venmo, and Twitter denies the statement and say the company is violating its policies by accessing data from their platform.


“Most websites want to be included in Google Search, and we give webmasters control over what information from their site is included in our search results, including the option to opt-out entirely,” said Google. “Clearview secretly collected image data of individuals without their consent, and in violation of rules explicitly forbidding them from doing so.”

-Alex Joseph, YouTube Spokesperson



In addition to collecting photos, Clearview allegedly uses them to train AI to identify people. Its AI can identify a person by comparing their picture to its database of three billion images from the internet, and the results are 99.6% accurate. It works even if the initial image fed into the tool is blurry or if the face is partially obscured, apparently. The app is used by more than 600 law enforcement agencies, ranging from local police departments to the F.B.I. and the Department of Homeland Security. Law enforcement officials told The Times that the app had helped them identify suspects in many criminal cases.

 

The Chicago Police Department, one of the largest in the U.S., pays roughly $50,000 for a two-year contract with the company. The department said only 30 members have exclusive access to the technology and it does not use the facial matching technology to conduct live surveillance. New Jersey Attorney General Gurbir Grewal recently ordered state law enforcement agencies to temporarily stop using the technology until they learn more.
 

Learn more: Facial recognition database used by U.S. police
 

Asked what his concerns about the technology were, Grewal said, "I'm not categorically opposed to facial recognition technology. I think used properly, it can help us solve criminal cases more quickly. It can help us apprehend child abusers, domestic terrorists." But he added, "What I am opposed to is the wide-scale collection of biometric information and the use of it without proper safeguards by law enforcement."
 

If it goes ahead with its legal plan, Clearview wouldn’t be the first company to try and use the First Amendment to defend its data scraping practices. In 2017, a data analytics company called hiQ Labs tried to use a similar argument when it sued LinkedIn so that it could continue scraping the social network for publically available data. And while it ultimately lost the case, at least one notable constitutional law expert took up the company’s argument.
 

Not long ago but Facebook agreed to pay a huge amount to settle a case of facial recognition. At the moment, there aren’t any federal laws that regulate facial recognition — though some cities such as San Francisco have partially banned the technology. It’s likely Google’s legal involvement with Clearview will force the government to address the issue before long.

Spotlight

For years now, we’ve heard that B2B buyers prefer to fly solo and will only consider speaking to a sales person when they are most of the way through their buyer’s journey. However, recent findings from our 2nd annual B2B Buyer Survey conducted in collaboration with PJA Advertising & Marketing revealed that buyers will not only speak to vendors earlier than expected, but they tend to reach out to vendors at the beginning of the buying process.


Other News

Acronis Recognized as a Visionary in Gartner 2020 Magic Quadrant for Data Center Backup and Recovery Solutions

Acronis | July 28, 2020

Acronis, a global leader in cyber protection, was positioned in the Visionaries quadrant in the Gartner 2020 Magic Quadrant for Data Center Backup and Recovery Solutions. According to the report, “the move toward public cloud, heightened concerns over ransomware, and complexities associated with backup and data management are forcing I&O leaders to rearchitect their backup infrastructure and explore alternative solutions. This research provides analyses of backup and recovery vendors.”

Read More

GENERAL AI

Spitch Launches in U.S. With Omnichannel Conversational AI Solutions

Spitch | March 09, 2022

Spitch.ai, global leader in conversational AI solutions, today announced its launch in the U.S. following 400% year over year growth and a successful first funding round in 2021. The company announces its arrival with its state-of-the-art omnichannel solution using Natural Language Processing (NLP), Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Machine Learning. The conversational AI market has grown 130% and continues to increase as businesses look for customizable solutions to optimize operations for efficiency and accuracy. AI-powered solutions were propelled forward during the global pandemic and continue to gain momentum, often led by existing multinational technology companies. Spitch.ai, however, was designed to work alongside its customers and adapt to their unique needs and enters the U.S. market ready to demonstrate true omnichannel capabilities. Its customizable end-to-end AI solution seamlessly integrates within existing infrastructure. It's robust, affordable, and efficient time to market gives companies of all sizes the opportunity to leverage AI through Virtual Assistants for text and voice, Speech Analytics and Voice Biometrics, Knowledge Base, Chat Platform and more. Recognized as a "Cool Vendor" by Gartner and in the 2021 Forrester report "Best Practices and Trends: Voice Biometrics", Spitch.ai's full stack of conversational technologies, Swiss precision and reliability makes Spitch.ai a unique contender in the competitive world of enterprise AI. The comprehensive set of tools, out-of-the-box (OOTB) models with low-code, no-code capabilities, and comprehensive analytics features, set the foundation for privacy and security supporting on-prem, cloud and hybrid implementation models. "We are thrilled to announce our official launch in the U.S. market following several years of positive growth, strategic partnerships, increased funding, and our expanding customer base. Our agile approach and reliable omnichannel solution proven throughout Europe will prove to be beneficial for our existing and future U.S. customers." Alexey Popov, CEO of Spitch.ai Spitch develops and maintains its own core technology with a focus on customer experience in the evolving era of the digital customer while reducing cost, managing risk, fraud, and compliance. The team includes members with extensive experience in the sector; both technology entrepreneurs and management experience at Fortune 500 multinationals such as Oracle, Genesys, Ericsson, Avaya, Yandex, SVOX, Nuance, BEA, and Swisscom. Spitch.ai customers across Europe and the U.S. range across the finance, insurance, health, technology, telecom, education, retail, public transport, the public sector, and government, and Spitch solutions handled over 50 million end-user interactions during the last year. The company plans to announce its U.S. brands and partnerships in coming weeks as well as the official opening of its first U.S. office. About Spitch.ai Spitch is a global provider of B2B and B2C Conversational AI solutions, headquartered in Switzerland since 2014 with a presence in many countries across Europe and now in North America. Spitch helps enterprises to better understand and serve their customers using Natural Language Processing (NLP), Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Machine Learning. It has more than 40 customers worldwide, among which Baloise Insurance, PostFinance, Gruppo Reale, Versicherungs Kammer Bayer, Swisscard, Migrosbank and others are soon to be announced.

Read More

Best dedicated server hosting providers of 2020

IONOS | August 14, 2020

Opting for a dedicated server means that you get an entire server to yourself. There's no sharing of CPU time, RAM or bandwidth, which means your website stays responsive at all times. Shared web hosting can appear to be amazing value, with feature-packed products available for just a few pounds every month. But the reality is often very different, and they're not always the bargains they seem. Very low prices probably mean the host is cramming more customers onto each server, for instance. Performance will be poor as there aren't enough resources to go around, and the extra load could mean more server problems and downtime.

Read More

AI TECH

Infosenseglobal Announces a No-Code and Free to Use AI Platform

Infosenseglobal | May 09, 2022

Infosenseglobal announced the community release of ML Sense, a first and unique, no code artificial intelligence platform to develop machine learning models in the most nimble and agile manner. The product comes out of the box with more than 40 machine and deep learning models ready to use. To use this product, end users can ingest data from your local desktop or various cloud sources in CSV or industry-standard formats. This is the very first release of the product since it announced its AI division last in February 2021. Infosenseglobal CEO Hitesh Ruparelia believes that his existing ERP customers could leverage this platform via simple predefined data connectors for finance, manufacturing, etc., that they could use for everyday AI/ML application needs. He believes ML Sense is a game-changer product. With its unique intuitive, and easy functionalities, customers can perform rapid experimentation and attain speeds never seen before. ML Sense is a SAAS offering. The 100% free-to-use community version has significant functionalities such as automatic feature selection and engineering, data transformation, scenario builder, hypothesis validation, etc. He further adds that these features would be our competitive advantage compared to existing products and create a niche market position for Infosenseglobal. With ML Sense, the business end-users are empowered to initiate and execute ML programs without the need for technical staff such as engineers and data scientists. Customers will be able to complete the program in days that would have taken weeks earlier. Additionally, they would need no knowledge or prior experience in programming, statistics, or advanced skills to implement and choose which ML models will work for their business scenario. "The good news is that this is just the beginning. ML sense platform is built on top of various open-source mainstream technologies to automate the lifecycle of machine learning applications. Our next goal is to launch this in the marketplace offered by the major cloud providers. The marketplace provides an option to deploy ML Sense in the customers' existing cloud ecosystem. The idea is to provide an alternative solution wherein the customers are not required to bring the data to our platform. This would address the data privacy and compliance-related concerns of our customers. Additionally, many more exciting features and cloud connectors are in the product pipeline soon to be released." Rajesh Hassija, CTO, Infosenseglobal Inc Established in 2006, Infosenseglobal has headquarters in the U.S. and India and offers leading technical business solutions. Backed by deep expertise and experience, Infosenseglobal specializes in creating and delivering bespoke artificial intelligence and machine learning applications for some of the world's leading businesses.

Read More

Spotlight

For years now, we’ve heard that B2B buyers prefer to fly solo and will only consider speaking to a sales person when they are most of the way through their buyer’s journey. However, recent findings from our 2nd annual B2B Buyer Survey conducted in collaboration with PJA Advertising & Marketing revealed that buyers will not only speak to vendors earlier than expected, but they tend to reach out to vendors at the beginning of the buying process.

Resources